Return to This Issue's Index
Return to Homepage
Something to Say: An Interview
by Janet Walker McDaniel
with Lee Smith
Lee Smith is a writer's writer. In her third collection of
short stories, News of the Spirit, she gives one of her
characters a memory that could have been her own:
Photo by Susan Raines
"More than anything else in the world, I wanted to be a writer.
I didn't want to learn to write, of course. I just wanted to be
a writer, and I often pictured myself poised at the foggy edge
of a cliff somewhere in the south of France, wearing a cape,
drawing furiously on a long cigarette, hollow-cheeked and haunted."
The author of ten novels, three short story collections, a
novella, Smith has received eight major writing awards, including
the Lila Wallace/Readers Digest Award (1995-1997), the Robert
Penn Warren Prize for Fiction (1991), and two O. Henry Awards
(1979 and 1981). The list of honors, awards, and grants
documenting her literary achievements goes on . . . Academy
Award in Fiction from the American Academy of Arts & Letters
(1999), Weatherford Award for Appalachian Literature (1988),
North Carolina Award for Literature (1984), Sir Walter Raleigh
Award for two of her books (1983 and 1989) and the Lyndhurst
Grant (1990-1992). Numerous periodicals and anthologies have
published her articles and stories -- Southern Review, Redbook,
The New York Times, and Atlantic, to name a few.
It takes only a glance at the titles of her books to determine
the interest she has in Southern Literature and the contributions
she has made toward preserving what is rapidly becoming a vanishing
lifestyle: The Last Day the Dogbushes Bloomed, Harper and Row,
1968; Something in the Wind, Harper and Row, 1971; Fancy Strut,
Harper and Row, 1973; Black Mountain Breakdown, Putnams, 1981;
Cakewalk, Putnams, 1981 (stories); Oral History, Putnams, 1983;
Family Linen, Putnams, 1985; Fair and Tender Ladies, Putnams,
1988; Me and My Baby View the Eclipse, Putnams, 1990 (stories);
The Devil's Dream, Putnams, 1992; Saving Grace, 1995; The
Christmas Letters, Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill, 1996 (novella);
and News of the Spirit, Putnams, 1997 (stories).
Although ties to the place of her birth are strongly represented
in her work, they are only one indication of this author's creative
output. Her professional and teaching experience as Professor of
English at North Carolina State University and as a Fellow at the
Center for Documentary Studies at Duke University has allowed her
to share more than the unique and universal characters and plots
her novels and stories offer. With a warmth and grace Southerners
are often noted for, Lee Smith shares her craft and the skills
she has developed with other writers, involving herself in
workshops and writer's conferences and encouraging adults and
students alike to take the risks involved in writing and to open
themselves to the world around them.
The fiction written by this Appalachian author has been called "a
redemptive work of art" (The Washington Post Book World's review
of her novel, Saving Grace). As she published book after book
her critics agreed on the importance of her voice. One of her
reviewers, writing about News of the Spirit, states in
the Memphis Commercial Appeal that Smith's most compelling
characteristic is "to light the page with the violence and vehemence of human
emotion and to express those qualities in prose of crystalline
purity and clarity." In the San Francisco Chronicle, one of
her short story collections, Me and My Baby View the Eclipse,
garnered praise with the reviewer's insistence that " . . . her
craft is so strong, it becomes transparent, and like the best
of storytellers, she knows how to get out of the way so the story
can tell itself." Even earlier, by almost two decades, her
stories were recognized, in a review of Cakewalk published in
The Houston Post, as provoking an " . . . unalloyed delight,
in the rich bourbon-flavored Southern tradition. Lee Smith often
strikes dead center the nerves of women's lives, and does it
with a grace and style that makes her one of the writers to
watch most closely."
Her extraordinary career has spanned more than three decades and,
though she recently retired from her teaching post at North
Carolina State University, Smith shows no signs of slowing down.
Rather, she began her retirement by leading a new generation of
writers through the development of a project published in
November, 2000, by Tryon Press of Chapel Hill. In an effort to
preserve the oral history of her own stomping ground in Grundy,
Virginia, she edited a book made up of interviews with the town's
older residents, collected by high school students there. A sense
of urgency filled this undertaking since the work had to be
completed before the implementation of a flood control plan
scheduled to devastate the downtown area.
Oral history is more than the title of her 1983 novel -- it is a way
of life. Whether she is reading from The Last Girls, her new novel
about five women who reunite to go down the Mississippi River on
the Delta Queen thirty-five years after they made the same trip
on a raft, or slapping her knee onstage during a performance of a
musical titled "Good Ol' Girls," which is based on characters
from her novels, this author chronicles life and death and
everything that goes on in between. Her appearance at the Southern
Women Writers Conference hosted by Berry College in Rome, Georgia,
where the musical stirred the souls of all in attendance,
highlighted her enthusiasm for her craft and colleagues and
resulted in the following exploration of her life and her work:
When did you start writing, and what led you to this creative
All I ever wanted to do was write. I was an only child and,
even when I was very little, my voracious appetite for reading
led to this desire. I hated for my favorite books to end, so I
would continue their stories by writing more onto the ends.
Did any other writer serve as a mentor to you?
Louis D. Rubin was my teacher and mentor. He started a
creative writing program at Hollin's College in Roanoke,
Virginia, where I was a student. That was in the early 60's
when few such programs existed. Later, he helped to found
Algonquin Books. Now he lives in Chapel Hill, North Carolina,
and through the years he has been a good friend.
How do you balance the demands of work and family?
Not well -- at every age it's hard to do. When my children were
little and when I started teaching, which was my full-time day
job for years, I felt guilty for taking this kind of time for
myself, like writing was my "secret vice." I retired from
teaching after eighteen years at North Carolina State University.
Before that I held other college-level teaching positions,
including at Duke University.
Out of all your creative ideas, how do you decide which projects
It's true that I often have a lot of ideas in mind. Usually, one
will seem most necessary at any given point. Sometimes deadlines
or outside factors dictate the time frame.
For example, I worked with a group of high school students in my
home town to preserve the oral history of some of the older
residents. The town, which often floods due to poor mine shaft
management, is scheduled to be permanently flooded. The people
who live there are moving to higher ground. The deadline had to
be met even though I was in the middle of a novel and working on
several short stories.
When you begin a new project, which usually comes to you first . . .
plot or character?
Sometimes I work on ideas for years, so that by the time I start
writing, I know the whole thing. I would say that the characters
What was the biggest obstacle you faced in publishing your books?
I had sort of a strange publishing experience, so it wasn't really
hard at first the way it is for most writers. I wrote a novel as
a senior in college for an independent study--for credit. I was
twenty-two years old, and the whole thing seemed deceptively easy.
Then I wrote a bad second novel and a third one which was published
by Harper & Row. While these gathered some nice reviews, they
made no money for the publishers.
At that time publishing was undergoing a change. Decisions began
to be dictated by financial reasons. When I wrote my fourth novel,
Black Mountain Breakdown, it was a dark and depressing story.
The publishers said they had already lost money on my work, so they
did not want this manuscript. I lost my agent and went for about
eight years without publishing anything other than a short story
or two (which kept me going). That's a long time for a writer.
During this period I decided to rethink the whole thing.
Black Mountain Breakdown had been a book I wanted to write,
but people were scared of themes like women's passivity and
characters who were all too willing to let other people determine
what they are going to do.
I thought I had been self-indulgent in taking the kind of time
from my family that it takes to write fiction. I decided to go
back to school and get a degree in Special Education in order to
make more money teaching. A sudden call from an agent changed
these plans. One of my writer friends had read my manuscript
and sent it to his agent who thought he could find a publisher
How has your writing changed over the years?
I think Black Mountain Breakdown was a turning point. As
I wrote this book, I was confronting my own doubts. Since then,
I've written other books with the same kind of themes, the kind
it's often hard to explore any other way.
How do you handle writing both short stories and novels?
Sometimes I stop in the middle of writing a novel and write a story.
Short stories seem to have a sense of urgency about them. Like
lyric poems, they are more like brief moments of intensity and
lend themselves to being written quickly, unlike a novel which
has a more leisurely pace.
Short stories seem like magic. Young writers often think they
must write quickly or lose the magic, but older writers know
they won't. They have learned they must rest the mind and
If you could start your writing career over, what would you
do differently, if anything?
I think I would remind myself early that passion in writing is
not enough. Having something worthy to say is really important.
In college I would pay more attention to other subjects . . .
history, science and sociology, for example. Rather than
reading mostly novels, I would absorb everything around me.
Do you think technology has influenced your work? If so,
Even though I have a website, I'm not really that involved with
the Internet. I have an assistant who helps with research and
puts my final drafts on disc. Most publishers want the manuscript
I think computers and the Internet can cause problems for writers.
Being able to do too much too fast is not always an advantage.
I do believe that access to so much information can be helpful
for students and others when it comes to literary criticism.
What advice would you give to today's young writers?
Absorb as much as you can and finally understand that what you write must have an idea. Read fiction constantly, find the writers you like, and try to emulate them.
What is it that makes southern writers unique?
They have innate storytelling ability. Even though the South has
changed enormously and is more like the rest of the country today
southerners still retain a narrative ability. My mother can
spin a story out of thin air about something as simple as a trip
to the grocery store. So can my daughter. Everything translates
to stories. We are not given to abstraction, and there is a kind
of "speakerly" delight in the stories which are often told in
Southern writers have an ear for dialogue, but this narrative urge
holds a secret flaw. We can't babble on without having an idea
or something truly important to say.
Why does she write? She says she does it "simply to
survive," to make sense of things. She considers the writing
process a way to examine her life and to find the answers to
questions she sometimes does not know she is asking. Certainly,
this way of listening to herself and to the others around her
gives her a personal strength. The press release for News of
the Spirit ("Lee Smith: In Her Own Words") probably describes
her feelings best with these words about self-examination:
"The story has always served this function, I believe,
from the beginning of time. In the telling of it we discover
who we are, why we exist, what we should do. It brings order
and delight. Its form is inherently pleasing, and deeply satisfying
to us. Because it has a beginning, a middle, and an end, it gives
a recognizable shape to the muddle and chaos of our lives."
In her book, The Christ-Haunted Landscape: Faith and Doubt in
Southern Fiction, Susan Ketchin quotes Lee Smith as saying
writing is a sort of salvation experience. This author and
professor at Duke University continues, "She does think of writing
in this way, and many of the other authors I interviewed for the
book did. Their work represents and reflects serious struggles
with faith and doubt."
Such issues resound throughout the body of Lee Smith's work. Along
with exploring what it means to be a woman -- and particularly a
Southern woman from Appalachia -- she manages to breathe life into
a wealth of characters who are looking for the same answers, from
within and without, that her readers are trying to find.
Lee Smith wouldn't have it any other way.
**About Janet Walker McDaniel
Janet Walker McDaniel is the author of
By Train At Night, a collection of sixteen
short stories (Henri Butler Press 2002), and
a Georgia Author of the Year Award nominee.
She works at the newspaper offices of
The Cedartown Standard, leads two local
writing groups and teaches computer